logo with tag line
IMA Associates Newsletter
December 2006


Did Horton Hear a Who or Whom?

Most of us are familiar with Dr. Suess’s delightful rhyming book Horton Hears a Who! In the story, Horton the Elephant hears a tiny speck of dust speaking to him. Although he cannot see them, the speck turns out to be the Whos, the tiny inhabitants of a microscopic planet called Who-ville.

Since the Whos in this children’s tale are creatures, the word “who” is used correctly as a noun. As a rule, however, “who” is a pronoun, and how and when to use it (or its related pronouns—whoever, whom, whomever) in a sentence can be as challenging for us as seeing the Whos was for Horton.

Here are tips and examples to help you determine the correct pronoun usage:

Is the pronoun a subject or an object?

Look at the clause following who or whoever and whom or whomever and how the pronoun is used.

  • Use who or whoever when it functions as the subject of a sentence or clause.
  • Use whom or whomever when it functions as the object of a verb or a preposition.

Can you substitute he/she or him/her?

  • Use who or whoever if you can substitute it with he or she.
  • Use whom or whomever if you can substitute it with him or her.

Example #1 We will choose whoever is the most qualified person to chair the committee.

In the sentence above, whoever serves as the subject of the clause is the most qualified person to chair the committee.

To verify this usage is correct, rewrite the sentence substituting he or she:

She is the most qualified person to chair the committee.
Example #2 With whom is David speaking on the phone?

In the sentence above whom is the object of the preposition with.

To verify this usage is correct, rewrite the sentence using him or her:

David is speaking with him on the phone.

Note: Although in the first example, whoever is the object of the verb choose, it functions as the subject of the verb is, which is why you would write whoever instead of whomever.

Here are a few more examples with possible substitutions:

  1. We have not decided who should cook dinner. (He should cook dinner.)
  2. Whom did the students vote for prom queen? (They voted for her.)
  3. Frank has lunch with whomever he pleases. (Frank has lunch with her.)
  4. Elaine will ask whoever is a Rolling Stones fan to join her at the concert. (He is a Rolling Stones fan.)

So, if we ask, “Whom did Horton hear?” We could answer, “He heard whoever made up that speck of dust—the Whos of Who-ville.”


holiday message

.


ilana picture

Ilana G. Traverse, Principal

Quick Links...

IMA's Programs & Services

About Us



Join our mailing list!